01 May Book Review of The Writers Journey: Mythic Structure for Writers, 2nd …
The Writer’s Journey: Mythic Structure for Writers — A Journey Worth Taking
Ah, The Writer’s Journey: Mythic Structure for Writers by Christopher Vogler! This book swept me back to my film school days when we pored over Vogler’s insights like treasure maps leading us to narrative gold. With the release of its third edition, I felt an irresistible urge to revisit this classic, eager to see how it would resonate with my current writing endeavors.
Vogler draws heavily on Joseph Campbell’s renowned work, The Hero with a Thousand Faces, delving into the universal structures and archetypes found in storytelling across cultures. It’s fascinating how he breaks down the hero’s journey into bite-sized, relatable steps: from the tranquil Ordinary World to the profound Return with the Elixir. This blueprint serves as a guiding light for writers and filmmakers alike — a reminder that deep down, our stories are woven from the same rich threads of human experience.
As I revisited these archetypes, I found myself reflecting on their presence in both my writing and the films I hold dear. The Call to Adventure, for instance, echoed in my own narrative journey, where moments of hesitation (the Refusal of the Call) often felt terrifyingly familiar. However, I couldn’t help but feel the weight of his formula at times. While Vogler effectively articulates how these principles apply to iconic films—Star Wars, anyone?—I often found myself questioning the practicality of aligning my stories with this structure. As I recalled my own struggles in film school, trying to map my narratives onto his steps, I resonated deeply with Vogler’s observation that some stories just don’t conform neatly to the mold, like Pulp Fiction, where he tries to make the Shapeshifter fit in an unconventional narrative.
Vogler’s writing style is approachable, making complex ideas accessible without dulling their intrigue. A particularly memorable takeaway for me was his poignant statement about the power of storytelling: “Story is the way we make sense of the world.” That line hit home, reminding me that no matter how structured, stories ultimately serve to connect us, to make sense of our myriad experiences.
However, as engaging as Vogler’s analyses and insights are, I shared some reservations echoed in the literary community about how formulaic structures run the risk of stifling creativity. While there’s merit in understanding the archetypes, it might not necessarily translate to seamless writing. Contrary to Vogler’s strengths as a story analyst, I felt a lack of direct guidance for writers seeking to create their masterpieces.
So, who would cherish this book? Aspiring screenwriters and storytellers eager to understand the mythic underpinnings of film narratives will find value here. It’s especially potent for those who appreciate analyzing films through a psychological lens. Yet, for others who prefer to create without confines, it’s wise to take Vogler’s insights as one of many tools in your storytelling toolkit, rather than a blueprint to follow.
In sum, The Writer’s Journey is a reflective read that invites readers to explore the depth of mythic storytelling. For me, it rekindled the spark of curiosity about narrative structure while also reminding me that the journey of writing is often as winding as the stories we wish to tell. I encourage fellow writers to take this journey — but remember, the path is yours to forge, even if it diverges from the archetypal maps laid out before you.
Discover more about The Writers Journey: Mythic Structure for Writers, 2nd … on GoodReads >>
