06 Sep Book Review of A Truce That Is Not Peace
A Reflection on Healing and Silence: A Review of A Truce That Is Not Peace by Miriam Toews
It’s rare to pick up a book and immediately feel a connection, a sense of shared vulnerability. When I opened A Truce That Is Not Peace, Miriam Toews’s latest nonfiction work, I was drawn not just by her reputation as a profound storyteller, but by a familiar theme of grappling with loss and the complexity of familial ties. As difficult as it is to write about grief, Toews does so with a quiet grace, inviting us into the intimate spaces of her heart and mind.
Toews weaves her sister Marj’s death by suicide into her own meditative journey to understand why she writes. It’s a touching act of love—her inquiry into her sister’s silence parallels her own compulsion to write. This memoir-like essay navigates intricate family dynamics, from Toews’s father’s struggles with bipolar disorder and his own silences to her role as a caregiver for her aging mother, Elvira. Each thread Toews pulls reveals not just her familial roots but a shared human experience with mental health, reminiscent of the pulse of life that circles around those we love. I found myself reflecting on my own family stories, the times when words failed us, and those fragments of connection that still resonated strongly.
One of the most poignant aspects of the book is Toews’s exploration of silence. She writes, “Marj punctuated her life with long periods of silence,” which becomes a haunting refrain. As I read, I felt the weight of those silences—both lingering and liberating. It’s remarkable to see how she flips the script on a personal narrative, transforming grief into a dialogue with her sister, even incorporating letters she wrote to Marj. These letters became lifelines—a testament to how writing is, indeed, more than just a craft; it is a means of survival.
The structure of the book is fragmented yet cohesive, beautifully playing with metaphor and memory. Toews introduces a concept she calls the "Wind Museum," a space where she questions the worth of her own creative efforts. This idea resonated deeply with me, as it echoes a common struggle among writers and creatives alike. Moreover, her encounters with her ex-husband regarding royalties serve as a window into the complex ways life can intertwine with art—a theme that is particularly relevant to anyone who has dipped their toes into the choppy waters of personal and professional relationships.
Toews captures moments of joy too, in the form of her mother and grandchildren—their vibrant presence somehow infusing the heavier narrative with light. I couldn’t help but celebrate these snippets of life, especially against the backdrop of the more somber reflections on existence and loss. The magnetic draw of her words kept me engaged and contemplative, a dance between sorrow and the affirmation of life.
As I wrapped up the last page, I felt profoundly moved. A Truce That Is Not Peace is not just a book about loss; it’s a deeper dive into understanding ourselves and each other. It is a gentle reminder to embrace silence, to find meaning in our fragmented efforts, and to cherish those we love dearly, even when they’re no longer with us.
I’d recommend this book to readers who appreciate memoirs that embrace complexity, those in search of a narrative that transcends traditional storytelling, and anyone reflective on the themes of grief, writing, and the challenges of mental health. If you’re wrestling with silence or the unnameable complexities of love and loss, Toews’s work will resonate with you.
I genuinely hope to run into Toews herself one day—perhaps on Queen West, heading to Type Books—and share how deeply her words have moved me. Until then, I’ll hold this book close, a companion through both turmoil and transformation.
Rating: 4.5 stars. A heartfelt thank you to Bloomsbury Publishing and NetGalley for the advance copy.
Discover more about A Truce That Is Not Peace on GoodReads >>
