07 May Book Review of Not Quite by the Book
Not Quite by the Book: A Literary Escape
There’s something magical about bookstores and the stories they cradle, which is likely why "Not Quite by the Book" by Annie England Noblin caught my eye. As a book blogger, I often find myself yearning for stories that intertwine not just good writing, but relatable character journeys and rich settings. With the promise of family drama, a historical twist, and a seemingly idyllic setting at an old manor once frequented by Emily Dickinson, I dove into this narrative with enthusiasm. However, while this book has moments of charm, it left me with mixed feelings.
A Journey of Self-Discovery
Emma Rini is a character many of us can empathize with. As the self-designated caretaker of her family bookstore, she bears the weight of her family’s expectations while yearning for a break—and perhaps a little love. This family drama weaves itself beautifully through Emma’s journey, showcasing her frustrations and aspirations. As she escapes to the manor, I appreciated how Noblin explored Emma’s growth, especially as she tries to emulate her role model, Emily Dickinson. The well-paced character arc felt authentic as Emma grapples with her identity and obligations, crafting a narrative that many can identify with.
The setting, naturally, deserves a mention. The manor feels alive with history, embodying a sense of nostalgia that resonates deeply. Noblin’s detailed descriptions of old stone walls and the chilly atmosphere painted a vivid picture, even making me shiver from the imagined cold! Those moments truly brought the setting to life and kept me engaged in Emma’s discovery.
The Romance That Left Me Wanting
However, this is where my excitement began to wane. The romance subplot entered with a bit of promise yet quickly devolved—what began as the intriguing potential of a grumpy-sunshine dynamic soon felt cluttered with miscommunication and exaggerated melodrama. Instead of joy, my reactions swung toward annoyance whenever love was in the air. I occasionally found myself questioning what connection there really was between Emma and the grumbling architect she begrudgingly teams up with. Their interactions felt sporadic, reducing the romantic tension to awkwardness rather than building a credible bond.
To add another layer of complexity, the scattered emphasis on miscommunication and secrets fostered a narrative that felt burdensome. By the time the ending arrived, where one might expect a blossoming love story and a happily-ever-after, I found myself more appreciative of Emma’s personal growth than the romantic resolution.
Final Thoughts
Overall, "Not Quite by the Book" is a mixed bag. While the thematic foundations—family, identity, and self-discovery—unfold beautifully, the romance left me feeling fragmented and somewhat disconnected. For those who adore family-centric stories with a hint of historical influence, this book might still strike a chord. But if you’re seeking a captivating romance along the way, you may find it lacking.
Though I had my reservations, I cherished the journey Emma undertook, even if the romance was not my cup of tea. Perhaps those deeply in love with Emily Dickinson or readers who relish nuanced family dynamics may find more joy in this tale. Thank you to NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing for the eARC; my review reflects my honest opinion. If you’re up for a story that leans heavily into personal growth over romance, "Not Quite by the Book" may just charm you in unexpected ways!
