01 May Book Review of Self-Editing for Fiction Writers: How to Edit Yourself …
Honest Reflections on Self-Editing for Fiction Writers by Rennie Browne and Dave King
I’ll be honest: when I picked up Self-Editing for Fiction Writers: How to Edit Yourself, I was a bit skeptical. After all, I’ve encountered my fair share of writing guides that felt more like rehashed advice than fresh insights. But I found myself intrigued—how could two seasoned editors, Rennie Browne and Dave King, encapsulate the self-editing process in a way that would resonate with someone like me, who has wandered through the labyrinth of roleplaying game supplements and fan fiction? I was curious to see if they had anything to offer that could elevate my own writing journey, particularly as I grapple with my first draft of a novel.
From page one, Browne and King delve into the essentials of good fiction: showing versus telling, characterization, dialogue mechanics, and the myriad other facets that create compelling narratives. As I read, I couldn’t help but feel a sense of camaraderie with the authors; they, too, understand the struggle of sculpting narratives into a polished form. Their voice comes through not just as instructors, but as companions who have witnessed the trials and triumphs of countless writers, offering both wisdom and a little tough love along the way.
What struck me most was their unflinching approach to critique. In each chapter, Browne and King don’t shy away from challenging readers. They use exercises with excerpts from literary giants like F. Scott Fitzgerald and Lewis Carroll, illustrating the shifting sands of writing norms over time. This not only helps to underscore their points about eliminate poor practices but also makes the guidance feel grounded in a wider literary conversation. It’s a reminder that, while every writer has a unique voice, there are established standards to keep in mind if one wishes to be publishable.
The pacing and organization of the book make for an engaging experience. Each chapter flows seamlessly into the next, and while some of the advice may feel familiar to seasoned writers, I found fresh perspectives tucked between the lines that inspired me. For instance, their insights on how to maintain a consistent point of view combined with practical strategies to tackle exposition were particularly enlightening for someone like me, who might be a tad too comfortable with their own writing quirks.
While I found much to appreciate, I also sensed some limitations. The primary focus on word and sentence-level composition can leave broader storytelling concerns, like pacing and character development, less explored. Many writers, especially those crafting genre fiction, might find themselves longing for specific examples from their narratives rather than only literary classics.
To that end, I wholeheartedly recommend Self-Editing for Fiction Writers to anyone looking to polish their work, especially those of us striving for publication. Whether you’re entrenched in the literary field or exploring genre writing, the principles laid out in this book serve as valuable tools. Browne and King may be aiming at the commercial fiction market, but their lessons on self-editing hold a universality that can benefit all writers.
As I stepped away from this book, I felt renewed in my own editing process and more confident in wielding the red pen over my first draft. If you’re a writer or aspiring author, I encourage you to give it a read. You may discover insights that resonate with you, just as they did with me.
In a sea of writing guides, Self-Editing for Fiction Writers offers a succinct, insightful beacon that could very well guide you toward honing your craft into something truly special.
Discover more about Self-Editing for Fiction Writers: How to Edit Yourself … on GoodReads >>
