02 May Book Review of The Art of Fiction: Notes on Craft for Young Writers
Embracing the Craft: A Reflection on The Art of Fiction by John Gardner
From the moment I picked up The Art of Fiction: Notes on Craft for Young Writers, I felt myself drawn into a world that both intimidated and excited me. John Gardner, a luminary in the realm of literary criticism and fiction writing, has crafted a book that promises insights into the art and craft of writing. As a burgeoning writer navigating the labyrinth of storytelling, I hoped this book would unlock some elusive understanding of my craft.
Gardner’s approach is fundamentally dichotomous. The first half of the book immerses us in philosophical musings about the essence of fiction, peppered with his palpable admiration for literary giants like Tolstoy and Melville. It was fascinating to explore the classical ideals of storytelling, yet I found myself occasionally recoiling at Gardner’s condescending tone. His frequent dismissal of modern literature teachers felt particularly out of place—instead of fostering dialogue, it felt like a gatekeeper’s warning, dissuading anyone who does not fit into his traditional mold.
Despite these reservations, Gardner’s command of the craft is irrefutable. He argues that fiction should truly be an "uninterrupted dream." I resonated deeply with this notion; it’s a beautiful way to encapsulate what we strive for as writers. However, I was sometimes left yearning for a broader perspective that appreciates both traditional and avant-garde storytelling styles. Gardner’s insights are primarily grounded in realist fiction, which—while rich and rewarding—limits those who wish to explore beyond its confines.
Moving into the latter half of the book, I found a treasure trove of pragmatic advice. Gardner adeptly dissects common pitfalls in writing. The detailed exploration of rhythm in prose was particularly enlightening for me. Analyzing sentences through the lens of poetic terminology like iambs and anapests opened my eyes to a level of nuance I hadn’t considered before. His chapter on plotting stands out too, enriched with examples that not only clarify concepts but also feel like a seasoned teacher guiding you through your own potential missteps.
One passage that lingered in my mind was Gardner’s discussion about “faults of soul.” This phrase encapsulates pitfalls like sentimentality and mannerism, providing an intriguing framework for thinking about our own narratives. While I couldn’t wholly subscribe to his orthodoxy, I appreciated how those reflections pushed me to scrutinize my own writing with more care.
In conclusion, I believe The Art of Fiction holds considerable value, especially for those interested in writing within more traditional structures. It certainly isn’t a one-size-fits-all guide; perhaps it’s best served alongside a contrasting voice that embraces a wider array of literary styles. For students, aspiring writers, or anyone looking to refine their writing craft, Gardner’s work can serve as a foundational text—though with the crucial awareness of its limitations. Personally, engaging with this book spurred a deeper reflection on my own writing journey, challenging me to strive for that dream-like quality in my narratives while navigating the delicate balance of staying true to my unique voice.
Discover more about The Art of Fiction: Notes on Craft for Young Writers on GoodReads >>
