13 Aug Book Review of The Best American Short Stories 2023
A Dive into the Unfolding Worlds of The Best American Short Stories 2023
As a book blogger with a penchant for exploring voices both familiar and novel, I was thrilled to grab a copy of The Best American Short Stories 2023, expertly curated by guest editor Dinah Cox. Having previously read the 2019 edition, I was eager to see how the landscape of contemporary short fiction has evolved over the past few years.
The anthology is a mix of feelings: some stories will resonate long after you close the book, while others might not make quite the same impact. One major trend I noted was the emphasis on personal narratives told predominantly in the first person—15 out of 20 stories. For those who love a straightforward point of view, this could be a treat; however, as a reader who craves a bit more experimentation, I found it slightly repetitive. Additionally, the collection steered clear of historical or genre fiction, leaning instead on contemporary realism, which felt a bit limiting for a "best of" anthology.
Cox clearly has a knack for spotting talent, and the anthology shines with a significant representation of female authors and writers of color, reflecting the rich tapestry of voices currently shaping modern literature. Stories delve into cultural identity, friendship, and the search for meaning, stepping beyond the often-challenging domestic sphere. For me, this was a refreshing focus, offering a deeper look into community ties and personal growth rather than the typical narratives centered around marriage or parenting.
Among the stories, "Do You Belong to Anybody?" by Maya Binyam stood out as my favorite. It presents a surreal journey back to Ethiopia and unfolds like a puzzle, inviting readers to engage deeply with both the text and its subtext. The narrator’s dry humor, wrapped in trauma and absurdity, resonates on multiple levels, sparking curiosity and a sense of connection.
Conversely, "Tender" by Cherline Bazile served as a lackluster introduction for me, drawing a crowded character landscape but failing to develop compelling emotional arcs in its brief format. It highlights a persistent struggle, yet remains surface-level, which disappointed my expectations for a powerful opening.
As I transitioned into the second half of the anthology, I found stories like "My Brother William" by Danica Li and "Bebo" by Jared Jackson far more engaging. They brought forth lush characterizations and explored themes of relationships and self-identity in ways that felt lived-in and genuine. Perhaps it’s a bias toward stories that allow me to empathize deeply, but these resonated strongly, showcasing the highs and lows of human connection in a poignant manner.
However, not every narrative succeeded in leaving a lasting impact. I found "The Mine" by Nathan Harris lacking authenticity due to its overly formal English and a feeling of distance from the locale it sought to represent. Such disjointedness sparked my thoughts on the idea of voice in storytelling, a theme I couldn’t help but chase throughout the collection.
Finishing The Best American Short Stories 2023, I felt a sense of satisfaction mixed with a tinge of disappointment over its missed opportunities for thematic and genre diversity. Yet, the collection introduced a wealth of new authors whose works I may seek out in the future—a testament to the anthology’s ultimate strength in expanding my reading horizons.
This volume is for readers who appreciate intimate narratives grounded in contemporary themes, especially those who enjoy thoughtful explorations of identity and belonging. While it may not cover the full breadth of the literary landscape, it successfully showcases a significant, vibrant collection of voices, many of which linger in the mind long after the final page is turned. In the end, while my heart might have yearned for more experimental pieces or narratives that venture into fantastical realms, I left with new insights about the everyday intricacies of life. After all, sometimes it’s the simplest stories that carry the heaviest weight.
Discover more about The Best American Short Stories 2023 on GoodReads >>
